When I look over the vast sea of fiction, I find language polluting the waters. Over and over again, it fouls what otherwise might have been a great book. And every clean secular novel I discover is cause for celebration, because they're so very rare. I don't know about you, but if there was a machine that could erase every obscenity out of books, I'd press that Big Red Button so fast, nobody would know what hit them.
Whether you're nodding along right now, or quirking your brow and thinking, 'Come on, Tracey, stop being a prude,' I hereby present my case—five reasons language should be scooped out of the fiction ocean like so much overgrown seaweed.
1. It can be a sign of unintelligence.
One doesn't require much of an IQ to string together a bunch of obscenities. In fact, it shows a much higher level of intelligence to be able to express anger, frustration, surprise, pleasure, etc. with a clean vocabulary. And I'm sorry, but the moment you start cussing, you've just slapped a label across your own forehead. You make it harder for me—or anyone—to respect you. This goes for real life, and it goes for books. Every time a character cusses, my respect for that character and for its author begins to drop.
2. It's uncreative, and it's lazy.
(Closely tied to the above reason.) It doesn't take much creativity to let loose a blue streak. "I can't believe that bleeping bleepity-bleep!" takes way less effort than, "I can't believe that backstabbing cad! Has he no sense of decency?" Not that one has to be quite so wordy or cheesy about it . . .
3. It's not that gritty.
Meaning, it takes a lot more than an arsenal of swear words to achieve a sense of gritty realism, if that's what the author is going for. A strong sense of setting, mood, and character goes a lot further than dialogue full of bleeps.
4. Readership.
Segment A of the population doesn't bat an eye at R-rated language. Segment B is generally repelled by it. So wouldn't it make sense to tone down (or eliminate!) the element that's chasing some of your readers away? Couldn't you appeal to a wider audience by mopping up your verbiage? I have a boundary when it comes to the swearing in books: cross that line, either in volume or severity, and I shut the book and leave it on the shelf. Most likely never to pick it up again. Mr./Mrs. Author, you just lost yourself a few dollars.
5. In fantasy, it's often unrealistic.
This one applies mainly to the fantasy genre. I was watching the movie Seventh Son with my dad the other night. It's high fantasy, okay, with dragons and monsters and a (ahem) typical beast-slaying plot. So when the characters started cussing using modern Earth words, that threw me for a loop! And this isn't the only movie or book I've encountered that's guilty of this believability-weakening flaw.
But there is a kind of language that I relish in a good fantasy tale--fictional profanity. Disclaimer: please don't give me cuss words that rhyme with the real ones. I skimmed through the first quarter of a book about little people living in a tree, and characters were dropping thinly disguised swears left, right, and center. Sure, a handful of them had to do with twigs, leaves, and other tree-related things, but the majority of the profanity was so close to the real thing, my brain translated it instantly. This is how NOT to write fictional oaths.
One of my favorite examples of well done fantasy swearing is found in the Tales of Goldstone Wood series by Anne Elisabeth Stengl. Dragons are highly feared and despised in her world, so naturally, they feature in the language. "Dragon's teeth," or "Dragon's eat you, ___!" appear often. So do references to powerful beings: "Lumè love me," "lights above," and "Iubdan's beard," just to name a few. This sort of language is just so fun to exclaim. The polite characters frown upon such usage, but we as readers don't. It accomplishes the purpose without even coming near real world equivalents.
So what are your opinions on bookish profanity? Does it bother you? Does it matter? Whether you're still nodding along at this point, or don't agree with me in the slightest, I'm interested to hear your thoughts!
Foul language gets on my nerves. It's not an easy thing to skip, and it can be scattered all over a book, like lego pieces across a floor. That is one of the many reasons why I find it so hard to find a truly great book.
ReplyDeleteI agree that swearing does show immaturity. But on the other hand, it seems to be human nature to shout something when angry/scared/in pain. What's an anti-swearing person to do? (for me, I end up making wookie noises. Unfortunately, I find it doesn't leave me more mature.)
This could make interesting fiction, actually. Imagine this: A character who is intent on keeping his or her language squeaky clean, yet he or she is constantly thrust into language-inducing circumstances. How does this character react? Rather than taking the easy way and having the character spew a few curses, the writer could have some fun with the character development.
EXACTLY my thoughts. And I love that Lego analogy! Yes, swearing makes it super hard to find good reads . . . along with a number of other content issues, the topmost being sexual. (Blegh. Am I the only one sick and tired of the book covers featuring shirtless guys or a kissing couple?)
DeleteThat's true. And in those situations, I do unfortunately find certain words springing to mind. (On the rare occasion, they spring further, which is *not* a good thing.) Wookie noises, lol, that's the best! XD Definitely a great alternative.
Hey, now that's an idea. That could be a lot of fun to play around with! ;D Thanks for weighing in. :)
Can I just give a big, resounding AMEN!!!!!!
ReplyDeleteThis post. THIS POST. Yes to all the things. EVERYTHING. I was totally nodding and going "Yes, yes, yes, yes, yes!" in my head while reading it. Especially #4! I know we've talked about it before, so you know my feelings on it. But come on! If an author wants to appeal to everyone then leave out the obscenities. No one minds if they're not there, but some of us definitely mind if they ARE. So just leave 'em out!
I've also totally thought about how it sounds way too modern in fantasy worlds. It doesn't even FIT. But things like the Goldstone Wood books were perfect and just helped build the world and make it come even more alive. It's a win, win all around.
Basically this is one of the bestest posts ever and I wish everyone in the world would read it. Thank you for sharing, Tracey! This was perfect!
LOL, Christine! Yes, #4 sprang from our discussion, actually. ;) And you put it so smartly: "No one minds if they're not there, but some of definitely mind if they ARE." Very true.
DeleteI know, right? After reading a Goldstone Wood book, I almost find myself saying "dragon's teeth" when I'm mad. XD
Haha, glad you enjoyed it! ^_^
So, I, erm, awkwardly have a problem with fictional cussing vs real cussing. I mean, what's different?? I always get confused at swearing because aren't we humans giving the words the power? THEY'RE JUST WORDS. XD At the same tiiiiime...I was brought up to not swear, so I basically don't! And when I write, depending on the genre, swearing just doesn't enter it. I don't think swearing is necessarily a sign of low intelligence, but I DO respect when a book limits swearing to appeal to a wider audience. But for me? Swearing makes zero problems.
ReplyDelete(But omg, I hate hate hate it when fantasies swear out of context. It NEEDS to be in context. I read a fantasy series with totally no deities and they kept say "oh my god" and it just bugged me so much because you can't USE that unless you HAVE a god in your world!! GAH. But yes, I like it when fantasies do it cleverly.)
ANYWAY. SUCH AN INTERESTING TOPIC!! I loved reading your thoughts on this!! XD
Good point there! There shouldn't really be a difference. I guess we could extend this to "Five Reasons Language Should Be Wiped Out, Period." Although, hey yeah, there's freedom of speech and all... XD
DeleteI guess the word *itself* has no power--it is, after all, simply letters strung together. But to me, it's the meaning and intentions behind it that's the problem. The word represents something unpleasant and offensive. I understand how it doesn't bother some people, though.
(I know! Come on, pay attention to your worldbuilding, authors! It's always a great touch when characters' diction reflects the world in which they live. Cleverness in that area is greatly appreciated by me as well.)
Thanks so much for weighing in, Cait! :D
That analogy of the ocean was simply wonderful, Tracey! This is a fantastic post. Oh, my word. Also, when it comes to readership, group A does not see the absence of swear words the same way group B reacts to their presence. Those words are offensive to the group B readership, but it wouldn't really bother group A to have them gone. Therefore it is actually more logical to omit them and attain a wider audience.
ReplyDeleteAnother thing to do with language is innuendos. Yeah, nothing may /happen/ in the book, but I still don't want to read what some think funny and I consider sacred.
Language is a mark of unintelligence and a lack of creativity. You are awesome, Tracey.
@Blue: Wookie noises? XD That's the best!
Thank you! Exaaaactly--if it's not there, people of either viewpoint hardly notice, but when it is present, some of us balk. But here I go repeating everything you just cleverly said. XD
DeleteYup. So true.
I don't know if you've heard of author Bryan Davis before, but he made an interesting remark in a post about a pitch conference he attended in New York. He was told that "...editors nowadays see profanity as too easy, ho-hum, and lacking cleverness. A good writer can provide cultural flavor and raw emotion without resorting to cursing." (http://theauthorschair.com/2015/03/25/the-new-york-city-pitch-conference-2015/)
Yes yes yes and yes! Wonderful post, Tracey! I agree with this so much. Foul language often makes me very annoyed at books and I often feel like I can't recommend a book I liked otherwise. Grrrr. It makes me so annoyed. Very good points, all! There has been the occasional time when I was reading a book and there was some "older", slightly milder maybe language that did sort of fit, especially in British books of a certain era, but the times when it DID fit are very rare and far in between. Mostly it's just super on-my-nerves. -_- So many books/shows/movies/what-have-you are just sullied and ruined by people throwing in totally random language and inappropriateness and I'm just left going NO. NO NO NO. (I mean, yes, there is freedom of speech, so in that sense I'm not going to complain TOO bad. BUT STILL. Argh.) (And yes, out-of-context things are the worst where they don't even BELONG there so it's obviously just there for no reason. >.<)
ReplyDeleteGreat post, thank you! :)
I feel ya, girl. "Grrr" indeed! But that totally makes sense about old-fashioned language. Even, say, the British use of 'bloody' is something that doesn't bother me. We shall just endeavor to revolutionize fiction then, won't we? You and me all the other lovely writers I know--we will change the world! XD
DeleteEverything you said was spot on. :)
I personally don't swear, and it does bother me that Y.A's now spew it like it's okay.
ReplyDeleteHere and there seems more realistic, and even then it does seem unnecessary. I can't say it bothers me too much because I do read and enjoy a lot of books, movies, and music that has swearing in it. I also have people in my life who have a bit of a potty mouth. I do try to keep my mouth clean, and my books. Because I think it can just make you seem sloppy or they can be used as fillers.
I personally would rather any medium not to have swearing, though.
:D Great post.
Yep, it's just tiring, isn't it?
DeleteThat can be rough when others around you swear often, but good for you for keeping your own vocabulary clean. :)
Me too. Thanks for commenting, Skye! :D
I have no problem with profanity in literature, as long as it's not just swearing for the sake of swearing (I get enough of that at work... I'm a high school teacher).
ReplyDeleteThat 'swearing for the sake of swearing' seems to be such a blurred line. I find it hard to pinpoint it sometimes.
DeleteOoh, I can imagine that job comes with a number of pains as well as joys (<--hopefully!).
Thanks for popping by! :)
I agree! I've often thought about number 4, also in relation to nudity and sex in movies, books, etc. Yeah, THESE people don't care, but THOSE people do. And THESE people can still enjoy a movie if it contains no swearing, sex, etc, but THOSE people have a harder time enjoying rampant filth.
ReplyDeleteAnyway, YES to fantasy swearing, also! XD It's actually weirdly super fun. X) I think I've actually utilized that in my current WIP. Mostly to do with stars, I think. Stars above, Stars help him, mild stuff, even for fantasy swearing. XD
Completely agree! It would just make sense to stop including those things in books and movies. Guaranteed, authors/moviemakers would make a lot more money off me if they went that route. XD
DeleteIt is, isn't it? I like your "stars" version. ^_^ That kind of swearing can be a great worldbuilding tool as well. In my fantasy series, I have a character swear by his country's greatest river. :P ("Great Bending River, we're all going to die!" Or something like that, lol.)
Ahahaha! I love that! Next time I feel my impending doom approaching, that's what I'll scream. XD
DeletePerfect. Hopefully that's not anytime soon... XD
DeleteI'm partially with you and partially not. Most of the time I do not like swearing especially in things such as blog posts where it's public domain. In books I hate excessive swearing or just random swearing when the book would be equally as clean without it (Like the random swears in the Divergent series). I closed one book after five pages because of the f-bombs on every page. The only time when I think swearing is okay is when the characters would logically swear like, say, drug-dealing gangsters. They would have mouths they don't want to kiss their mother's with. It's just realistic. That said having them swear every other word (even if many do in real life) is a tad excessive, but have enough to give the realism I can tolerate. Other than that sole reason, I agree with your points especially the intelligence one and even then if a character would logically swear especially the protagonist a "he swore" will do.
ReplyDeletestoritorigrace.blogspot.com
Yeah, I get what you're saying. And I think there does come a point, especially in books for an older/more mature audience, where *some* profanity might be justified for the reasons you mentioned. I know in the excerpts of "The Scent of Her Soul" that Bryan Davis has posted on his blog, a couple characters swore mildly. I personally have always gone the "he swore" route (unless it's a fantasy character, in which case, they can spout all sorts of fictional words).
DeleteThe occasional language was one of my main complaints with the Divergent series too. That, and Tris's definition of "going slow" in her relationship with Four is...not exactly slow.
Anyway, thanks so much for your comment! :) There's a little grey in this area, I do admit.
This post pretty much sums up how I feel about language in books and movies. If the story is engaging enough, sometimes I'll just bleep it out in my head as I read, but the books would all just be so much better if the swearing wasn't there. Oh, and if you want a book where the swears are intentionally bleeped out, you should read Dangerous by Shannon Hale. (also because there is fun sic-fi epicness) :)
ReplyDelete(Just got back to the realm of the internet, so here I am replying!) Yeah, I do that too with books that are interesting enough to merit a read (despite their occasional language). Ooh, Shannon Hale, you say? I've enjoyed several of her books, and Dangerous sounds great. Thanks for the recommendation!
Delete